We Are Legion  

Posted by Scott Oden in , ,

'We' being afficianados of all things Orcish, apparently. During my downtime from writing LoC (and believe me, there's not much downtime), I picked up the first book in a new fantasy trilogy called Queen of the Orcs: King's Property by Morgan Howell. From the Random House website:

Born into hardship, Dar learns to rely on herself alone. When her family betrays her, Dar is conscripted into King Kregant’s army and its brutal campaign to conquer a neighboring country. Now she is bound as a slave to a dreaded regiment of orcs, creatures legendary for their savagery and battle prowess.

Rather than cower, Dar rises to the challenge. She learns the unique culture and language of the orcs, survives treachery from both allies and enemies, and struggles to understand a mystical gift that brings her dark, prophetic visions. As the war escalates–amid nightmarish combat and shattering loss–Dar must seize a single chance at freedom.

I was skeptical at first, but it turned out to be quite good. Morgan Howell (who is a HE, though I first thought otherwise . . . it's the name 'Morgan' that threw me -- and shame on me, because I know a guy named Morgan) has taken his Orcs in a whole new, and distinctively non-Tolkienesque, direction. These are a far cry from the brutal greenskins of WoW or Oblivion, and a whole different species compared to the piggish orcs of D&D. Large and muscular (and appearing in my mind's eye as hairless mountain gorillas in plain and functional armor), Howell's Orcs possess a matriarchal society with strong Native American overtones. They are less warlike than Humans, but far superior in the physical act of fighting due to their innate strength and speed. That they are efficient killers gives them a reputation for savagery among their human allies.

The story follows a woman, Dar, who is conscripted into the army of King Kregant as -- essentially -- a cross between a slave and a camp follower. She's an interesting character and it's equally interesting to watch as she learns to navigate the intricacies of Orc culture. My only complaint -- well, I actually have two: first, I wanted more page-time for the Orcs -- more battle scenes, etc. Hopefully, the future volumes will go into stronger martial detail. My second gripe has to do with the Spartan nature of Howell's prose. Don't get me wrong, he's a fine writer with an excellent grasp of character. But, David Durham's Acacia has left me spoiled and on the prowl for new sources of lush and poetic description. I want to see fantasy worlds come alive like that, and while Howell's Orcs were fully-realized and fascinating the balance of the world seemed typically medieval European.

But, Morgan Howell has hooked me and I'll be back for more.

This entry was posted on Tuesday, August 07, 2007 at Tuesday, August 07, 2007 and is filed under , , . You can follow any responses to this entry through the comments feed .

11 comments

Hum, less warlike than humans? They don't really sound like what I thought Orcs would be like. Why not call them something else?

10:58 AM

Oooh . . . good question, Charles! While I can't speak for Mr. Howell, I believe it has to do with creative reinvention -- taking a staple race of fantasy, chipping away at the old conventions and stereotypes, and giving them essentially 'new life'. That's what I plan to do in my own Orc book (which will come after the Assassin trilogy*). I liken it to REH's use of historical place names in the Hyborian Age. It was a way to benefit from the gravitas and ingrained recognition of a particular name (such as 'Argos' or 'Turan') while still presenting something new.




*Click the 'Kingdoms of the Middle Sea' link to the right for a brief preview and my own fictional etymology of the name 'Orc'. I hope to add more info to that blog as time permits.

11:27 PM

It's always difficult deciding when to continue a tradition and when the tradition has been twisted enough to become something new. How far can you push an Orc before it's no longer an orc? Could be an intersting debate.

10:24 AM

Indeed it could be. For myself, I want the 'chassis', so to speak, of the Orc but with enough changes to the engine to make them sympathetic to human readers. So, my own Orcs look like the canonical Tolkien Orc (and I abhor the 'greenskin' depictions prevalent in gaming), though less twisted and foul-seeming. Into that, I've thrust the psychology of a barbarian -- more Geseric than Conan, with a dash of the medieval Turk and Afghan thrown in. Capable of viciousness and brutality, sure, but not inherently evil. And even some admirable traits.

Most of all, I wanted to dispense with the notion that they needed some greater will (like Sauron) in order to function beyond a tribal level. So, some choose their own destinies while others cling to the staus quo (much like us). Mr. Howell's Orcs go quite a bit further afield than mine, though not quite as far as Stan Nicholl's Orcs -- which acted far more human than most humans in his world.

I still consider them Orcs, though I can see how others might disagree.

2:44 PM

Mary Gentle's "Grunts" is also a wonderfully creative look at orcs. I recommend it!

8:34 AM

Someone needs to compile the Definitive Bibliography of Orc Fiction (which, after writing that title, sounds like something I might try -- I dig on bibliographies).

Thanks, La Gringa, for reminding me of Ms. Gentle . . . I've been meaning to pick up 'Grunts'. And, thanks for the mention at The Swivet! :)

9:05 AM

Do we know if Morgan Howell is a man or a woman? I can't find any information on the author anywhere.

Please cite any information you have on this question.

12:55 PM

I always imagined orcs as a cross between feudal samari and Kiligons.

12:59 PM

Hi Urlord. According to the copyright notice, which I don't have with me at the moment, 'Morgan Howell' is a psuedonym for a guy named -- if my memory serves -- William Howell. I'll double check again and let you know.

Thanks for stopping by!

1:13 PM

Scott, the name you want is William H. Hubbell.

For a look at orcs as primitive hunter/gatherers with an Australian Aborigine vibe, look up John Wick's Orkworld

11:37 AM

Thanks, Mythusmage! I'll have to add Orkworld to my growing list of things to read ;)

11:48 PM

Post a Comment